Case study
A D2C skincare brand selling in India and the UAE
The situation
Paid social costs rose every quarter. The dashboard showed healthy returns, but most of the sales it claimed came from customers who would have bought again anyway. Nobody could say which spend brought in a new customer.
In practice
The brand's best-selling serum is advertised to past buyers on Instagram every day. We switch that spend off for two weeks in one city and leave it on in another. If repeat sales hold in both, the money moves to search ads for people comparing serums for the first time.
What Whack! does
- 01Separate new from repeat
We rebuild tracking so every order is tagged as a first purchase or a repeat, and report the two apart.
- 02Set the target on profit
Campaigns are judged on profit from new customers after product cost and shipping, not on the platform's own return figure.
- 03Test creative every week
Five to ten new ads go live each week, built around one idea at a time, so we learn what actually changes behaviour.
- 04Move money to intent
Budget shifts each week towards the searches, audiences and markets where people are already looking to buy.
What we measure
- 01Cost to acquire a new customer
- 02Payback period
- 03Share of revenue from new buyers
